🇫🇷 CHOTTIN Philippe · FRANCE

78rank
-34.9Butler · 180 bds
-0.19per board
±4.2swing
-0.67vs par /bd · #118/135
+0.07adjusted /bd
Butler per round: -21.4 -12.4 -11.8 13.2 1.8 12 4.3 -12.2 2.2 -11.1 -12.6 16.8 -5.1 -11 12.4by round

vs par split: bidding -0.24 · play -0.43

Strength of schedule: opponents averaged +0.26/bd (a tough draw) → opponent-adjusted +0.07/bd

Card play — on target: opening leads 76.7% #84 of 135 · declarer play 62.5% #112 of 135 · defence 84.4% #73 of 135

Card play by contract type — on target
vs NTvs a suit
Opening leads76.9% (13)76.7% (30)
Declarer play58.3% (12)63.9% (36)
Defence85.7% (28)83.9% (62)

Opening leads by suit led: ♠ 88.9% (9) · ♥ 75.0% (12) · ♦ 72.7% (11) · ♣ 72.7% (11)

vs par by strain: NT +0.56 (52) · a suit -1.16 (128)

vs par by level: part-score -1.12 (72) · game -0.06 (101) · slam -4.71 (7)

By role: declaring +0.27/bd (-2.57 vs par · 90) · defending -0.66/bd (+1.23 vs par · 90)

By vulnerability: vulnerable -0.30/bd (-0.52 vs par · 90) · not vulnerable -0.08/bd (-0.81 vs par · 90)

By round↑ top

RoundPartnerOpponentsRoomBdsButlerAvgvs par
Round 1D.PilonE.Rodwell – B.LevinClosed12-21.4-1.78-2.67
Round 3D.PilonS.Chan – A.ChengClosed12-12.4-1.03-1.75
Round 4D.PilonC.Thompson – G.HashimotoOpen12-11.8-0.98-2.00
Round 5D.PilonJ.Skipper – J.SkipperClosed12+13.2+1.10+1.83
Round 7D.PilonW.Fornasari – R.AngeleriClosed12+1.8+0.15-0.50
Round 8D.PilonM.Ince – N.KoktenOpen12+12.0+1.00+0.08
Round 9D.PilonB.Das – P.BardhanOpen12+4.3+0.36+0.67
Round 12D.PilonB.Spears – B.ShenkinClosed12-12.2-1.02-0.50
Round 13D.PilonM.Blat – P.BizonClosed12+2.2+0.18+0.75
Round 14D.PilonA.Braithwaite – A.De LiveraOpen12-11.1-0.92-3.25
Round 15D.PilonD.Cohen – J.EngelOpen12-12.6-1.05-2.83
Round 18D.PilonJ.Verhees – P.CardwellClosed12+16.8+1.40-0.67
Round 20D.PilonS.Schou – J.HansenOpen12-5.1-0.42-1.75
Round 21D.PilonN.Buchlev – N.SchilhartClosed12-11.0-0.92+1.50
Round 22D.PilonR.Bryant – S.GreenOpen12+12.4+1.03+1.08

Every board — best Butler first↑ top

vs par = IMPs this pair scored above (+) or below (−) the board’s double-dummy par — what bidding and play (theirs and the opponents’) added or gave away against perfect play.

ButlerRoundOpponentsBdContractLeadResvs par
+12.7Round 9🇮🇳 INDIA244♣x♠A-4+9
+11.6Round 8🇹🇷 TURKIYE65♥x♦J=+11
+10.8Round 3🇭🇰 HONG KONG CHINA213NT♠4+1+1
+10.1Round 12🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND23NT♠4=+10
+8.4Round 9🇮🇳 INDIA221NT♠5=+11
+7.9Round 4🇨🇭 SWITZERLAND54♥♣8+2+13
+7.9Round 7🇦🇷 ARGENTINA203NT♠K+1+0
+7.0Round 21🇩🇪 GERMANY184♥♥3-1+12
+6.4Round 14🇦🇺 AUSTRALIA96♠♦Q+1-11
+6.3Round 22🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND105♣♦A-2+8
+6.0Round 13🇵🇱 POLAND144♠♥Q-1+5
+5.9Round 8🇹🇷 TURKIYE54♠♦3-1+12
+5.4Round 20🇩🇰 DENMARK114♠♣2+1+0
+5.1Round 13🇵🇱 POLAND184♥♦5-3+5
+5.1Round 15🇮🇱 ISRAEL134♠♣5-2+3
+5.0Round 18🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS73NT♥5=+0
+4.9Round 22🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND65♥♦A=+0
+4.9Round 22🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND123NTx♣3-1+7
+4.8Round 18🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS104♠♥2+1+4
+4.7Round 4🇨🇭 SWITZERLAND14♠♥4+1+0
+4.7Round 4🇨🇭 SWITZERLAND104♥♣J=-1
+4.5Round 18🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS85♦♥8=+3
+4.3Round 5🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND193NT♠3-2+6
+4.3Round 18🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS33NT♦Q-1+5
+4.2Round 20🇩🇰 DENMARK12♠♣J=+5
+4.1Round 1🇺🇸 U.S.A.11NT♣8=+5
+4.1Round 5🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND235♣♥A=+3
+4.1Round 7🇦🇷 ARGENTINA212♦♠2-1+12
+3.9Round 3🇭🇰 HONG KONG CHINA145♠♣A+2+10
+3.7Round 14🇦🇺 AUSTRALIA23NT♥5+2+4
+3.7Round 18🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS24♠♥5-1+6
+3.7Round 21🇩🇪 GERMANY174♥♦K-2+0
+3.6Round 7🇦🇷 ARGENTINA165♣♠A-1+5
+3.6Round 21🇩🇪 GERMANY243♠♦A+2+6
+3.3Round 18🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS14♥♦A=+0
+3.1Round 5🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND243♦♣3+1+6
+3.1Round 15🇮🇱 ISRAEL163♦♥A-2+11
+3.1Round 22🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND71NT♥5-1+6
+2.8Round 20🇩🇰 DENMARK124♥♣5+2+1
+2.7Round 7🇦🇷 ARGENTINA244♠♥4-1+5
+2.7Round 9🇮🇳 INDIA232♥♥A-1+0
+2.6Round 5🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND163♠♣7+1+11
+2.6Round 8🇹🇷 TURKIYE113♥♠4=+1
+2.5Round 5🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND172♣♠A+1+1
+2.4Round 13🇵🇱 POLAND193♠♠K-1+4
+2.4Round 20🇩🇰 DENMARK52♠♥A+2+2
+2.3Round 3🇭🇰 HONG KONG CHINA174♥♦2-1+5
+2.3Round 18🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS93NT♦2+4-12
+2.2Round 13🇵🇱 POLAND211NT♦A+1+6
+2.2Round 18🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS42NT♠J-2+8
+2.2Round 22🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND24♠♥5=+0
+2.1Round 3🇭🇰 HONG KONG CHINA164♠♣J+1+0
+2.1Round 9🇮🇳 INDIA184♥♠3=-1
+2.0Round 20🇩🇰 DENMARK63NT♠3+1+0
+1.9Round 13🇵🇱 POLAND133NT♣7+1-1
+1.8Round 18🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS113NT♥10=-1
+1.7Round 7🇦🇷 ARGENTINA224♦♠A-1+5
+1.7Round 22🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND31NT♦J=+0
+1.5Round 1🇺🇸 U.S.A.114♠♥Q+1-10
+1.4Round 15🇮🇱 ISRAEL214♥♠4=+1
+1.3Round 8🇹🇷 TURKIYE13NT♥8+3+1
+1.3Round 12🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND104♠♦2+1+0
+1.3Round 15🇮🇱 ISRAEL192♠♣A-1-1
+1.3Round 22🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND113NT♥3-2+5
+1.2Round 3🇭🇰 HONG KONG CHINA192♠♥K=+0
+1.2Round 8🇹🇷 TURKIYE123NT♥3-1+6
+1.2Round 18🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS122♠♥A=+0
+1.1Round 5🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND212♥♠J+1-7
+1.1Round 13🇵🇱 POLAND233NT♦7+2+0
+1.0Round 12🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND124NT♠7+3+10
+0.9Round 12🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND96♠♥9=+0
+0.8Round 9🇮🇳 INDIA163NT♥3=+0
+0.7Round 1🇺🇸 U.S.A.72♠♥2+1+10
+0.7Round 7🇦🇷 ARGENTINA145♦♠A+1-11
+0.7Round 12🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND52NT♠2=+13
+0.6Round 21🇩🇪 GERMANY164♥x♠A-1+5
+0.5Round 4🇨🇭 SWITZERLAND74♥♣A+1+0
+0.4Round 5🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND181NT♠10+2+1
+0.4Round 5🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND223♥♠J-1-5
+0.4Round 7🇦🇷 ARGENTINA132♥♦10+1+0
+0.4Round 8🇹🇷 TURKIYE104♠♣A=+0
+0.4Round 14🇦🇺 AUSTRALIA83♦♥A=+1
+0.4Round 22🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND93NT♣3+2+10
+0.3Round 4🇨🇭 SWITZERLAND24♣♦4=-7
+0.3Round 14🇦🇺 AUSTRALIA114♠♥J=-11
+0.1Round 4🇨🇭 SWITZERLAND92♣♣7-1-5
+0.1Round 15🇮🇱 ISRAEL181NT♠3-1-3
-0.0Round 9🇮🇳 INDIA193NT♠2=+1
-0.1Round 4🇨🇭 SWITZERLAND42♠♥K+1+0
-0.1Round 8🇹🇷 TURKIYE24♥♠2-1+2
-0.1Round 8🇹🇷 TURKIYE31NT♥Q-3-10
-0.1Round 22🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND12♥♣K+1-7
-0.2Round 9🇮🇳 INDIA131NT♣K=+0
-0.2Round 15🇮🇱 ISRAEL173NT♦6=+1
-0.3Round 12🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND12♠♣A-1-3
-0.4Round 5🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND204♠♣4+1+0
-0.4Round 13🇵🇱 POLAND163♦♦8+1+0
-0.5Round 20🇩🇰 DENMARK82♠♦5+2-6
-0.6Round 3🇭🇰 HONG KONG CHINA183♠♦3+1-10
-0.6Round 5🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND155♣x♠5-1-6
-0.7Round 1🇺🇸 U.S.A.52♥♣A+1+0
-0.7Round 20🇩🇰 DENMARK103NT♠K=+13
-1.0Round 3🇭🇰 HONG KONG CHINA203♣♥10-1-5
-1.0Round 8🇹🇷 TURKIYE43NT♦4-2-8
-1.0Round 13🇵🇱 POLAND242♠♠A+1-1
-1.0Round 14🇦🇺 AUSTRALIA62♥♦2+1-1
-1.1Round 8🇹🇷 TURKIYE92♠♦7=-6
-1.1Round 14🇦🇺 AUSTRALIA74♠♣10+1+0
-1.2Round 9🇮🇳 INDIA201NT♦2+1+0
-1.3Round 5🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND134♥♦7+2+13
-1.3Round 7🇦🇷 ARGENTINA193♥♣A=+0
-1.3Round 12🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND84♥♦7+1+0
-1.4Round 21🇩🇪 GERMANY193NT♦9+1+1
-1.5Round 7🇦🇷 ARGENTINA233NT♠2+2+0
-1.6Round 22🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND51NT♥A+1-1
-1.7Round 13🇵🇱 POLAND173♠♣6=+0
-1.8Round 4🇨🇭 SWITZERLAND31NT♥A=-5
-1.8Round 9🇮🇳 INDIA172♥♥10+1-7
-1.9Round 20🇩🇰 DENMARK94♥♣6+1+0
-2.0Round 1🇺🇸 U.S.A.24♠♦Q-1-10
-2.0Round 9🇮🇳 INDIA143♥♦A+1-4
-2.0Round 14🇦🇺 AUSTRALIA34♥♠Q-2+1
-2.3Round 1🇺🇸 U.S.A.123♥♠K=-7
-2.3Round 14🇦🇺 AUSTRALIA104♥♠A=+0
-2.3Round 14🇦🇺 AUSTRALIA124♥♠2-1-5
-2.3Round 15🇮🇱 ISRAEL242♥♣J-1-9
-2.5Round 8🇹🇷 TURKIYE74♠♦K=-3
-2.5Round 15🇮🇱 ISRAEL145♣♦A-3-7
-2.7Round 1🇺🇸 U.S.A.33♥♣J-1-5
-2.7Round 21🇩🇪 GERMANY143NT♦10=+0
-2.8Round 1🇺🇸 U.S.A.42♥♣3=+1
-2.9Round 15🇮🇱 ISRAEL223♣♠5-2-5
-2.9Round 21🇩🇪 GERMANY214♠♥5+2-1
-3.0Round 5🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND144♠♦3+2-1
-3.0Round 21🇩🇪 GERMANY233NT♦5+1-1
-3.1Round 1🇺🇸 U.S.A.94♠♣5-3-4
-3.2Round 22🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND44♣♥A=-11
-3.3Round 12🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND32NT♠Q-2-5
-3.3Round 13🇵🇱 POLAND223♥♣K-1-6
-3.3Round 14🇦🇺 AUSTRALIA52♥♦4-4-7
-3.3Round 20🇩🇰 DENMARK21♠x♥2=-11
-3.3Round 21🇩🇪 GERMANY153NT♣4=+1
-3.4Round 20🇩🇰 DENMARK44♠♣A-2-12
-3.5Round 3🇭🇰 HONG KONG CHINA245♠♣10+2-14
-3.6Round 7🇦🇷 ARGENTINA184♥♣7-2-6
-3.7Round 21🇩🇪 GERMANY226♠♦3=+0
-3.8Round 13🇵🇱 POLAND153NT♠9=+0
-3.8Round 14🇦🇺 AUSTRALIA44♠♥2=+0
-3.9Round 1🇺🇸 U.S.A.82♠♥5-3-2
-4.0Round 21🇩🇪 GERMANY202NT♥3-1-6
-4.1Round 4🇨🇭 SWITZERLAND111♠♦K+1-5
-4.5Round 12🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND62♠♦K=-6
-4.6Round 4🇨🇭 SWITZERLAND123NT♥Q+1+0
-4.7Round 1🇺🇸 U.S.A.66♥♥8=+0
-4.7Round 9🇮🇳 INDIA215♥x♠Q-3+0
-4.7Round 20🇩🇰 DENMARK34♥♠A+1-1
-4.8Round 12🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND74♥♠5-1-12
-4.8Round 15🇮🇱 ISRAEL153NT♠3-1-12
-4.9Round 21🇩🇪 GERMANY134♠♦7=+1
-5.0Round 12🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND45♦♣K=-3
-5.1Round 3🇭🇰 HONG KONG CHINA224♠♣Q=-1
-5.4Round 15🇮🇱 ISRAEL203♥♦5+1-1
-5.5Round 1🇺🇸 U.S.A.103NT♣7=-10
-5.5Round 7🇦🇷 ARGENTINA173♦♥Q+1-6
-5.5Round 15🇮🇱 ISRAEL234♦♥8-1-12
-5.7Round 3🇭🇰 HONG KONG CHINA154♥♣K+2-3
-6.1Round 14🇦🇺 AUSTRALIA14♥♣K-1-10
-6.2Round 8🇹🇷 TURKIYE81NTx♠10-2-5
-6.3Round 13🇵🇱 POLAND203NT♠Q=-3
-7.0Round 12🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND115♣♣6-1-10
-7.2Round 18🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS63NT♣A-3-10
-7.4Round 7🇦🇷 ARGENTINA153NT♣4-1-10
-7.4Round 20🇩🇰 DENMARK74♦♥K-1-12
-7.5Round 22🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND86♦♥7+1-4
-8.1Round 3🇭🇰 HONG KONG CHINA234♦♥A=-1
-8.7Round 3🇭🇰 HONG KONG CHINA134♠♥6=-3
-9.1Round 4🇨🇭 SWITZERLAND85♠x♣A-4+3
-9.1Round 18🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS54♠♦3=-11
-10.3Round 4🇨🇭 SWITZERLAND66♠♦6-1-17
-12.5Round 9🇮🇳 INDIA156♥♦9=-1