🇫🇷 PUILLET Carole · FRANCE

48rank
+61.2Butler · 256 bds
+0.24per board
±4.3swing
+0.14vs par /bd · #63/140
+0.35adjusted /bd
Butler per round: 11.6 5.8 5.3 23.5 2.2 -16.6 30.8 6.5 9.9 29.7 -37.1 12 4.4 -16.7 1.2 -11.3by round

vs par split: bidding +0.21 · play -0.07

Strength of schedule: opponents averaged +0.11/bd (a tough draw) → opponent-adjusted +0.35/bd

Card play — on target: opening leads 79.1% #56 of 140 · declarer play 67.8% #111 of 140 · defence 84.6% #85 of 140

Card play by contract type — on target
vs NTvs a suit
Opening leads55.6% (18)87.8% (49)
Declarer play58.8% (17)71.4% (42)
Defence76.7% (43)88.2% (93)

Opening leads by suit led: ♠ 76.9% (13) · ♥ 93.1% (29) · ♦ 75.0% (12) · ♣ 53.8% (13)

vs par by strain: NT -0.38 (85) · a suit +0.40 (171)

vs par by level: part-score +1.85 (98) · game -0.41 (142) · slam -5.38 (16)

By role: declaring +0.00/bd (-2.49 vs par · 120) · defending +0.45/bd (+2.46 vs par · 136)

By vulnerability: vulnerable -0.19/bd (-0.62 vs par · 128) · not vulnerable +0.67/bd (+0.91 vs par · 128)

By round↑ top

RoundPartnerOpponentsRoomBdsButlerAvgvs par
Round 2V.BessisJ.Stansby – S.ShiOpen16+11.6+0.72+3.75
Round 3V.BessisE.Khonicheva – D.RakhmaniClosed16+5.8+0.36+0.75
Round 4V.BessisA.Kshirsagar – R.BakeriClosed16+5.3+0.33-1.25
Round 5V.BessisK.Howard – S.ParmananClosed16+23.5+1.47+0.44
Round 7V.BessisB.Houmoller – S.Buus ThomsenClosed16+2.2+0.14+2.31
Round 9V.BessisX.Zuo – N.WangClosed16-16.6-1.04-0.81
Round 11V.BessisV.Armstrong – T.RawsonClosed16+30.8+1.93+1.06
Round 12V.BessisA.Yanagisawa – Y.FukuyoshiOpen16+6.5+0.41+1.06
Round 14V.BessisM.Verbeek – W.Van ZwolOpen16+9.9+0.62-1.06
Round 15V.BessisC.Bernstein – S.WheelerOpen16+29.7+1.86+1.50
Round 16V.BessisC.Gibbons – J.GibbonsClosed16-37.1-2.32-2.31
Round 17V.BessisY.Lin – Y.ChenOpen16+12.0+0.75+0.62
Round 19V.BessisP.Leslie – S.PunchOpen16+4.4+0.28-0.38
Round 20V.BessisK.Dufrat – J.ZmudaClosed16-16.7-1.04-3.19
Round 21V.BessisK.Bertheau – J.LarssonOpen16+1.2+0.07+1.00
Round 23V.BessisM.Harding – A.FuglestadOpen16-11.3-0.71-1.25

Every board — best Butler first↑ top

vs par = IMPs this pair scored above (+) or below (−) the board’s double-dummy par — what bidding and play (theirs and the opponents’) added or gave away against perfect play.

ButlerRoundOpponentsBdContractLeadResvs par
+11.9Round 15🇺🇸 USA 222♦♣K-2+13
+11.7Round 3🇷🇺 RUSSIA126♦♣K=+0
+10.8Round 11🇿🇦 SOUTH AFRICA45♦♦8=+0
+10.7Round 11🇿🇦 SOUTH AFRICA67♠♥3=+0
+10.7Round 15🇺🇸 USA 243NTx♠Q-2+12
+10.1Round 17🇹🇼 CHINESE TAIPEI106♥♣10=+0
+10.0Round 17🇹🇼 CHINESE TAIPEI13NTx♥Q-3+9
+9.7Round 12🇯🇵 JAPAN174♥x♦2+1+9
+8.5Round 16🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND303♣x♥2-3+12
+8.3Round 5🇹🇹 TRINIDAD & TOBAGO103NT♥4+1+0
+8.1Round 7🇩🇰 DENMARK163NT♥Q-2+11
+7.5Round 15🇺🇸 USA 2153NT♦7-2+8
+7.2Round 17🇹🇼 CHINESE TAIPEI84♥x♠2=+12
+7.1Round 11🇿🇦 SOUTH AFRICA24♥♦A=+7
+7.0Round 19🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND123♥x♠K-2+9
+6.8Round 2🇺🇸 USA 1224NT♠10-2+11
+6.7Round 11🇿🇦 SOUTH AFRICA95♥x♦2-1+11
+6.7Round 20🇵🇱 POLAND194♥x♦7=+5
+6.5Round 3🇷🇺 RUSSIA105♥x♦K=+14
+6.5Round 7🇩🇰 DENMARK93NT♠2+1+0
+6.5Round 15🇺🇸 USA 214♥♦Q+1+1
+6.4Round 7🇩🇰 DENMARK143NT♥7-1+10
+6.3Round 4🇮🇳 INDIA243NT♠A+1+4
+6.3Round 5🇹🇹 TRINIDAD & TOBAGO84♠♣10-1+10
+6.3Round 5🇹🇹 TRINIDAD & TOBAGO134♠♦9=+10
+6.0Round 14🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS204♥♣6-1+6
+5.9Round 21🇸🇪 SWEDEN115♦♥A+1+11
+5.8Round 23🇳🇴 NORWAY53NT♠4=+0
+5.7Round 2🇺🇸 USA 1206♦♥2+1+13
+5.6Round 2🇺🇸 USA 1303NT♠4-1+10
+5.6Round 4🇮🇳 INDIA274♥x♠10-2+5
+5.5Round 7🇩🇰 DENMARK73NT♥4-3+4
+5.3Round 20🇵🇱 POLAND323♣♠K-3+4
+5.1Round 7🇩🇰 DENMARK62♠♦5-2+6
+5.1Round 20🇵🇱 POLAND203NT♠6=+0
+5.0Round 5🇹🇹 TRINIDAD & TOBAGO13NT♣10-2+11
+5.0Round 9🇨🇳 CHINA122♠♦6=+9
+4.8Round 14🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS243NT♥Q=+0
+4.7Round 16🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND324♠♣5-1+10
+4.5Round 2🇺🇸 USA 1285♥♦10+1+13
+4.5Round 21🇸🇪 SWEDEN161NT♣7-2+3
+4.3Round 9🇨🇳 CHINA63♠♥6=+0
+4.2Round 7🇩🇰 DENMARK135♦x♠8-1+8
+4.2Round 9🇨🇳 CHINA134♠♦K+2+10
+4.2Round 14🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS303♦♠7-1+5
+4.2Round 20🇵🇱 POLAND285♦x♥K-4-12
+4.0Round 3🇷🇺 RUSSIA33NT♠4=+7
+3.7Round 9🇨🇳 CHINA143NT♠7+1+0
+3.5Round 17🇹🇼 CHINESE TAIPEI32♥♦A-3+2
+3.5Round 23🇳🇴 NORWAY113♦♦9=-1
+3.4Round 14🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS173♦♥K-3+2
+3.4Round 14🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS185♣♠A=-2
+3.4Round 21🇸🇪 SWEDEN91NT♥4=+5
+3.3Round 14🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS253♦♣K-2-1
+3.2Round 5🇹🇹 TRINIDAD & TOBAGO114♠♥Q-3+6
+3.2Round 12🇯🇵 JAPAN314♠♣10+2+1
+3.2Round 19🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND22♦♣9-1+5
+3.1Round 7🇩🇰 DENMARK154♠♥10+1+0
+3.1Round 15🇺🇸 USA 273♥♠J+1-1
+3.0Round 12🇯🇵 JAPAN221NT♦4+1+1
+3.0Round 23🇳🇴 NORWAY22♠♥4-1+5
+3.0Round 23🇳🇴 NORWAY143NT♦4-1+10
+2.8Round 11🇿🇦 SOUTH AFRICA142♠♠Q-1-2
+2.7Round 3🇷🇺 RUSSIA133NT♣3-1+6
+2.7Round 5🇹🇹 TRINIDAD & TOBAGO63♣♦2=+0
+2.7Round 12🇯🇵 JAPAN283♦♥J=+5
+2.6Round 3🇷🇺 RUSSIA143♠♣A=+1
+2.5Round 2🇺🇸 USA 1315♦♥A-1+5
+2.4Round 15🇺🇸 USA 293♣♦J=+8
+2.4Round 16🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND261♠♦K-1+5
+2.3Round 17🇹🇼 CHINESE TAIPEI132♥♦A=+0
+2.2Round 5🇹🇹 TRINIDAD & TOBAGO53NT♦3+1+0
+2.1Round 5🇹🇹 TRINIDAD & TOBAGO43♣♥8-1+5
+2.1Round 11🇿🇦 SOUTH AFRICA134♣♥4-2-7
+2.1Round 15🇺🇸 USA 264♣♥J=+0
+2.0Round 4🇮🇳 INDIA315♥♦5=+0
+2.0Round 21🇸🇪 SWEDEN82♠♦J+1+6
+1.9Round 11🇿🇦 SOUTH AFRICA153NT♣K+4-14
+1.9Round 23🇳🇴 NORWAY74♠♥7-1+6
+1.8Round 14🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS273♥♠3-3+0
+1.8Round 17🇹🇼 CHINESE TAIPEI53NT♦10-2+13
+1.7Round 4🇮🇳 INDIA185♥♦K-1+5
+1.7Round 5🇹🇹 TRINIDAD & TOBAGO71NT♠4=+2
+1.7Round 12🇯🇵 JAPAN244♥♣3+1+0
+1.7Round 15🇺🇸 USA 2101♥♣8+2+0
+1.7Round 15🇺🇸 USA 2163♠♣K+1+2
+1.6Round 4🇮🇳 INDIA283♠♦8-2+2
+1.6Round 21🇸🇪 SWEDEN12♥♥3+2+1
+1.6Round 21🇸🇪 SWEDEN73♠♥A-3+14
+1.5Round 2🇺🇸 USA 1182♠♦K-2+2
+1.5Round 4🇮🇳 INDIA224♦♠A-2+6
+1.5Round 4🇮🇳 INDIA234♥♦3+1-13
+1.5Round 19🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND133NT♥3-2+7
+1.4Round 14🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS314♥♠10+1+1
+1.4Round 17🇹🇼 CHINESE TAIPEI73NT♠8+3+1
+1.4Round 19🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND42♥♣5+1+10
+1.3Round 11🇿🇦 SOUTH AFRICA11NT♠2+2+1
+1.3Round 12🇯🇵 JAPAN252♠♦5=+11
+1.3Round 19🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND143NT♠5+3-14
+1.2Round 2🇺🇸 USA 1175♥♠2+1+1
+1.2Round 9🇨🇳 CHINA113♥♣5=+6
+1.1Round 2🇺🇸 USA 1321NT♣K=-1
+1.1Round 19🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND93♦♣Q=-1
+1.0Round 3🇷🇺 RUSSIA93♣♠A+1+11
+1.0Round 4🇮🇳 INDIA304♠♠5+1-11
+1.0Round 9🇨🇳 CHINA74♥♣7-1+12
+0.9Round 15🇺🇸 USA 2113NT♥5+2+11
+0.8Round 2🇺🇸 USA 1243NT♥Q+1+1
+0.8Round 5🇹🇹 TRINIDAD & TOBAGO154♥♥7+1+0
+0.8Round 7🇩🇰 DENMARK53♠♦2-1+10
+0.8Round 19🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND63♦♣3=+0
+0.7Round 11🇿🇦 SOUTH AFRICA75♦♣A-3+9
+0.6Round 19🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND53NT♦5+1+0
+0.6Round 20🇵🇱 POLAND304♥♠6=+1
+0.6Round 23🇳🇴 NORWAY12NT♥3-2-1
+0.5Round 3🇷🇺 RUSSIA11NT♠K=-2
+0.5Round 7🇩🇰 DENMARK14♠♣A-1-2
+0.5Round 14🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS214♠♦6=+0
+0.5Round 19🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND114♠♥J=+0
+0.5Round 21🇸🇪 SWEDEN31NT♦5-1+3
+0.3Round 11🇿🇦 SOUTH AFRICA112NT♦3=-1
+0.3Round 19🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND151NT♥3+1+0
+0.3Round 20🇵🇱 POLAND181NT♣3=+5
+0.2Round 12🇯🇵 JAPAN184♥♥6+1+0
+0.1Round 2🇺🇸 USA 1254♠♥6-1+5
+0.1Round 19🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND13NT♠5+2-1
-0.0Round 2🇺🇸 USA 1263NT♥4=+0
+0.0Round 3🇷🇺 RUSSIA84♣♥4-1+3
-0.0Round 4🇮🇳 INDIA324♠♥5=+0
-0.0Round 9🇨🇳 CHINA12♥♦J-1+2
+0.0Round 12🇯🇵 JAPAN324♠♣K+1+0
+0.0Round 15🇺🇸 USA 256♠♣A=+0
-0.0Round 17🇹🇼 CHINESE TAIPEI62♥♦5+2+6
+0.0Round 21🇸🇪 SWEDEN143♥♣J=+0
-0.1Round 3🇷🇺 RUSSIA46♥♣10+1-13
-0.1Round 4🇮🇳 INDIA204♠♠5+1+0
-0.1Round 12🇯🇵 JAPAN201NT♠Q-2+9
-0.1Round 12🇯🇵 JAPAN273♣♥K+2+6
-0.2Round 4🇮🇳 INDIA262♥♠5=+6
-0.2Round 9🇨🇳 CHINA56♠♦8+1-11
-0.2Round 11🇿🇦 SOUTH AFRICA51NT♠9=+11
-0.2Round 14🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS293NT♥6+1+1
-0.2Round 14🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS324♠♦A+1+0
-0.2Round 20🇵🇱 POLAND312NT♠6=+0
-0.3Round 9🇨🇳 CHINA24♠♦5+3-10
-0.3Round 17🇹🇼 CHINESE TAIPEI123♥♦Q-3+10
-0.3Round 23🇳🇴 NORWAY66♠♥10+1-11
-0.4Round 4🇮🇳 INDIA253NT♠2+2-13
-0.4Round 19🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND71NT♥4+1+9
-0.5Round 5🇹🇹 TRINIDAD & TOBAGO94♠♦A+1-1
-0.5Round 14🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS193♣♥K=-5
-0.5Round 21🇸🇪 SWEDEN23NT♠10+1-1
-0.5Round 21🇸🇪 SWEDEN54♥♠J+1+0
-0.6Round 16🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND294♠♥K+1+0
-0.7Round 9🇨🇳 CHINA84♠♥2+1+0
-0.7Round 20🇵🇱 POLAND292♥♥2+1+10
-0.7Round 23🇳🇴 NORWAY124♠♣4+1+0
-0.8Round 3🇷🇺 RUSSIA24♥♥2=+0
-0.9Round 12🇯🇵 JAPAN304♠♥A=-3
-0.9Round 17🇹🇼 CHINESE TAIPEI144♥♠Q+1+0
-0.9Round 20🇵🇱 POLAND213NT♦5+1-1
-0.9Round 21🇸🇪 SWEDEN42♠♥2+1-1
-1.0Round 3🇷🇺 RUSSIA63NT♦6-3-6
-1.0Round 3🇷🇺 RUSSIA163NT♥3+2+0
-1.0Round 5🇹🇹 TRINIDAD & TOBAGO22NT♦5-1-5
-1.0Round 14🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS283NT♦J+1+1
-1.0Round 16🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND172♠♣10=+0
-1.0Round 21🇸🇪 SWEDEN104♥♣A+1+0
-1.0Round 23🇳🇴 NORWAY95♦♥3+1+13
-1.0Round 23🇳🇴 NORWAY104♥♦7-2-9
-1.1Round 11🇿🇦 SOUTH AFRICA163NT♦4+2-2
-1.1Round 23🇳🇴 NORWAY32NT♠3-2-5
-1.2Round 11🇿🇦 SOUTH AFRICA124♠♥2+1+13
-1.4Round 12🇯🇵 JAPAN233NT♣4+1-1
-1.4Round 19🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND163♦♥K+1+0
-1.5Round 4🇮🇳 INDIA193♠♥2-1+8
-1.6Round 2🇺🇸 USA 1294♥♥3=+1
-1.6Round 16🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND223NT♣8+1+0
-1.7Round 9🇨🇳 CHINA102♥♣7+2-1
-1.7Round 15🇺🇸 USA 282♦♠J-1+2
-1.7Round 16🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND276♥♦2=+0
-1.7Round 16🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND313♠♥2-1-8
-1.8Round 15🇺🇸 USA 232NT♣7+2-10
-1.8Round 17🇹🇼 CHINESE TAIPEI93NT♠4=+0
-1.8Round 21🇸🇪 SWEDEN154♠♥3=+0
-1.9Round 17🇹🇼 CHINESE TAIPEI113♦♣A+2-1
-2.0Round 3🇷🇺 RUSSIA115♠♣7=+11
-2.1Round 5🇹🇹 TRINIDAD & TOBAGO143NT♣2-2-6
-2.1Round 20🇵🇱 POLAND244♥♦8-2-5
-2.2Round 12🇯🇵 JAPAN262♠♥4-1-5
-2.2Round 16🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND202♥♣K+1-1
-2.5Round 5🇹🇹 TRINIDAD & TOBAGO164♦♥10-1-2
-2.6Round 7🇩🇰 DENMARK81NT♣2+2-1
-2.6Round 11🇿🇦 SOUTH AFRICA82♠♥2-1-5
-2.6Round 12🇯🇵 JAPAN194♥♦J-2-3
-2.6Round 16🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND185♣♥10-1-10
-2.7Round 4🇮🇳 INDIA173♣♥A=+1
-2.7Round 16🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND282♣♠3+1+0
-2.8Round 20🇵🇱 POLAND175♣x♥3-3-2
-3.0Round 19🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND104♠♦A-2-8
-3.0Round 23🇳🇴 NORWAY133♦♣4-2-7
-3.1Round 17🇹🇼 CHINESE TAIPEI164♥♦10-1-12
-3.1Round 21🇸🇪 SWEDEN64♠♣A+2-11
-3.1Round 23🇳🇴 NORWAY152♠♥7-1-5
-3.2Round 2🇺🇸 USA 1233NT♣5=+0
-3.2Round 7🇩🇰 DENMARK43♣♥K+1+0
-3.2Round 17🇹🇼 CHINESE TAIPEI25♣♥K-2-6
-3.3Round 17🇹🇼 CHINESE TAIPEI155♥♠Q=-14
-3.4Round 3🇷🇺 RUSSIA73NT♠7-2-8
-3.4Round 4🇮🇳 INDIA212NT♥5+1-7
-3.4Round 12🇯🇵 JAPAN217♠♥5=+0
-3.4Round 14🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS263NT♥3=+0
-3.6Round 2🇺🇸 USA 1193NT♠6+1-1
-3.7Round 11🇿🇦 SOUTH AFRICA103♠♥5-1-3
-3.7Round 15🇺🇸 USA 2144♣♥Q-1-5
-3.8Round 3🇷🇺 RUSSIA53NT♥5+1+1
-3.9Round 19🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND83NT♣J-1-5
-4.1Round 9🇨🇳 CHINA93♥x♦K-2-2
-4.1Round 20🇵🇱 POLAND252♥♠3-2-7
-4.2Round 2🇺🇸 USA 1213♥♠A=+0
-4.2Round 7🇩🇰 DENMARK113NT♠3-3-7
-4.3Round 5🇹🇹 TRINIDAD & TOBAGO34♠♦10-1-12
-4.3Round 15🇺🇸 USA 2121NT♠4=-5
-4.3Round 23🇳🇴 NORWAY163♠♥7+3+2
-4.6Round 12🇯🇵 JAPAN294♥♦J+2-13
-4.7Round 5🇹🇹 TRINIDAD & TOBAGO123NT♦6+3-11
-4.7Round 7🇩🇰 DENMARK123♥♣10=+10
-4.7Round 19🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 SCOTLAND33NT♥J+3-17
-4.8Round 11🇿🇦 SOUTH AFRICA33NT♣8+1-1
-4.8Round 21🇸🇪 SWEDEN133NT♣2-2-8
-4.8Round 23🇳🇴 NORWAY84♥♦A-3-6
-4.9Round 14🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS224♥♠6-1-12
-5.0Round 16🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND213NT♠4=-10
-5.0Round 16🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND233♦♥A-2-3
-5.6Round 2🇺🇸 USA 1273NT♦4=+0
-5.7Round 21🇸🇪 SWEDEN123NT♠7-1-6
-6.0Round 20🇵🇱 POLAND224♥♠J-1-14
-6.3Round 9🇨🇳 CHINA151NT♦A+1+1
-6.4Round 9🇨🇳 CHINA45♥x♠A-3-16
-6.5Round 7🇩🇰 DENMARK24♥♣J=+0
-6.7Round 9🇨🇳 CHINA166♦♣7+1-1
-6.9Round 16🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND255♥x♦K-1-5
-6.9Round 20🇵🇱 POLAND276♥♦J=-10
-7.3Round 15🇺🇸 USA 2133NT♦9-1-12
-7.6Round 4🇮🇳 INDIA294♥♣3-1-13
-7.6Round 20🇵🇱 POLAND234♠♥4-1-12
-7.6Round 20🇵🇱 POLAND264♥♦J+1-13
-7.7Round 7🇩🇰 DENMARK36♠♣Q-2-13
-8.4Round 16🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND196♠♥Q-2-13
-8.7Round 14🇳🇱 NETHERLANDS233NT♥4-2-13
-9.1Round 7🇩🇰 DENMARK103NT♣2=+1
-9.6Round 9🇨🇳 CHINA33NT♥8-1-12
-9.8Round 17🇹🇼 CHINESE TAIPEI43NT♠5=-10
-9.8Round 23🇳🇴 NORWAY44♠♥A=-11
-11.1Round 3🇷🇺 RUSSIA156♠♥Q-1-13
-13.3Round 16🇳🇿 NEW ZEALAND247NT♣10-1-14